Contact Us

Sweetness... your way

Welcome to Simply Sweet Brooklyn! We are an insured NYS registered home processor located in the Bay Ridge neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY. We do not currently operate from a storefront so all inquiries must be submitted through our contact form.

Our Current Offerings

Use the navigation bar to view our custom offerings on cakes, cookies and treats!

Submit an inquiry HERE and review our current policies below.

Allergen Notice: Our products may contain some or all of the following: milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, citrus and wheat.


Note regarding nut allergies: We take great care in avoiding cross contamination for nut allergies, but we are not a certified nut-free facility. The only products that contain nut-based ingredients are our Nutella Buttercream (hazelnuts) and White Cake (almond extract). We do not use peanuts in any of our products or recipes.

Please notify us in your inquiry of any food allergies. Due to our liability insurance, we politely decline any orders where exposure to an allergen listed above, even through cross-contamination, could potentially cause anaphylaxis.  


Cake, Cupcake, Truffles & Cake Pop Flavors:



Funfetti Vanilla+


Red Velvet+

White Velvet+

White (contains almond extract)

Rainbow Vanilla (subject to additional fee - not available for cake pops)

Pink Velvet

Blue Velvet

Cookies & Cream

+Denotes popular/frequently ordered flavors


Chocolate Mousse

White Chocolate Mousse

Raspberry White Chocolate Mousse

Strawberry Jam

Raspberry Jam

Chocolate Ganache

White Chocolate Ganache

Any flavor buttercream listed ->

Premium Fillings: (Subject to additional $5-$15 fee depending on cake size)

Strawberries and Cream

Dulce de Leche

Nutella (contains hazelnuts)

Cannoli Cream

Vanilla Custard


Cream Cheese
Cookies & Cream


What our customers are saying

I've never been a fan of ornately decorated cakes and cookies. I cannot tell you how many times someone has enthusiastically handed me a beautifully decorated cookie or slice of cake and said, "Oh, you'll love it!"

And I did not love it. Why? Because it tasted like disappointment and sadness. I always thought that in order to achieve a beautiful cookie or cake the baker needed to sacrifice the taste of the baked good. I don't want to waste my time and calories on a cookie or cake pop that looks amazing but tastes like a hockey puck.

But what if I told you that it is possible to have a beautiful treat that also tastes amazing? Jaimie at Simply Sweet Brooklyn is an artist, a culinary chemist, a true magician. She has cracked the code on sugar cookies, producing a cookie sturdy enough to support incredible designs, yet soft and light enough to enjoy. Her cake pops are moist and delicious, and almost look too good to eat - almost. Plus, working with Jaimie is a pleasure; she was able to take my half-baked ideas and produce beautiful designs that captured our theme for the day.

So, lesson learned. Baked goods can be delectable and beautiful at the same time. Everyone at the baptism was raving about these treats! 

Diana B., Rockville Centre, NY

Each cookie and cake is made with love and yumminess. I am not a big cookie or cake lover, but Simply Sweet Brooklyn has converted me. Jaimie is amazing and a delight to plan any event with. I’ve gotten so many compliments on the goodies she makes for my events. If you are in the market for something beautiful, sexy and delicious call Simply Sweet Brooklyn.

Lenise R., Warwick, NY

I had ordered a cake from Simply Sweet Brooklyn. The cake was gorgeous and was absolutely delicious. I’ll be ordering all my future cakes and cupcakes from here.

Michelle L., Brooklyn, NY

The best cakes and cookies. Jaimie pays such close attention to detail. If you are looking for something unique, reasonably priced, and taste delicious, she is the one to go to.

Lynn D., Albany, NY

Just had the most Amazing cake from Simply Sweet Brooklyn. Outrageously beautiful with a taste to match!!! Both kids & adults loved it. Will definitely be using Simply Sweet again in the future.

Gail B., Brooklyn, NY


It takes many hands to deliver the best custom baked goods to you. Ok, not really... it's basically just Jaimie.

Jaimie P.

Owner, Jack of All Cake Trades, Master of Some

Jaimie started baking alongside her mother at a young age. In 2019, she decided to officially launch Simply Sweet Brooklyn at the urging of a friend. After more than a decade working in another industry, she's finally putting that fine arts degree to work that her father paid for.

William P.

"Mr. Sweet"

Will works long and hard at his day job to keep the lights on at Simply Sweet Brooklyn. He's also the Head of Facilities, Master 3D Printer Technician and Fixer of All Things Jaimie Breaks.

Gavin P.

VP, Distractions

Gavin heads up the distraction department at Simply Sweet Brooklyn. Whenever the timeline is tight, he's sure to be getting into some serious trouble. While he loves to watch the creations in progress, he takes great pleasure in critiquing the final output and lives up to "Mom Tested, Kid Approved". He also likes to remind Jaimie that he DOES NOT like Peppa Pig, but will still give it a thumbs up.

Shane P.

Senior Director, Product

Shane has been overseeing product testing and development since 2009. He's a big frosting fanatic and will be the first to say whether something is market worthy, aka "doesn't suck". You say "most kids hate fondant", Shane says "challenge accepted."